Follow by Email

Monday, November 23, 2009

Open Letter to Congresswoman Betty McCollum, Who Prides Herself on Her "Common Sense"

Betty McCollum from Minnesota's Fourth District was one of 36 members of Congress, all but three Democrats, who recently voted against the House resolution condemning the Goldstone report. According to her website, "Congresswoman McCollum brings a common sense, Minnesota perspective to her work".

On January 9 of this year, when Operation Cast Lead was underway, McCollum, in a speech before the House of Representatives, stated:

"Despite the fact too many Israeli citizens are under great stress from Hamas rockets, these weapons do not represent an existential threat to Israel. Rather than a serious military challenge, these rockets are like a drug gang that uses drive by shootings as a tactic to terrify a neighborhood. When is the solution to this type of terror for authorities to lay waste to the neighborhood?"

McCollum claimed in her speech that "after 13 days of warfare it is reported by officials in Gaza that more than 750 people are dead, of which 40 percent are women and children." The Israeli Defense Forces at the end of the operation stated that of 1,166 Gazans who died in the operation, 709 were Palestinian combatants, 295 were male non-combatants, 49 were women and 89 were children.

My open letter to McCollum, who is shown in her website snuggling with Obama after Obama was awarded his "richly deserved" Nobel Peace Prize, appears below:


When voting against the House resolution condemning the Goldstone report, you declared: "American-made white phosphorus shells were used by Israel in civilian areas causing horrible burns to Palestinian children, yet this resolution refuses to seek the truth?"

You want the truth? I also want the truth? Where were you when more than 10,000 mortar shells, rockets and missiles were fired from "civilian areas" in Gaza at civilians in southern Israel from 2001-2009? Did you ever visit the Israeli children who lost limbs from these attacks? Would you and your family be willing to live almost a decade under such fire? Think about it: Israeli children wet their beds rather than venture out of their safe rooms, because they had only 30 seconds from the sound of an alarm to return to safety.

Did you bother to read the entirety of the Goldstone Report? You obviously did not. Apparently it doesn't bother you that the members of this commission had already declared their enmity to Israel before the "investigation" had begun.

Does it bother you that the allegations of Hamas were accepted by the Goldstone commission without validation or verification? It was also alleged by Hamas that Israel is distributing aphrodisiac chewing gum in Gaza to subvert the morality of Gaza's youth. Shall we also seek the truth of this allegation?

Does it bother you that the charter of Hamas calls for the indiscriminate murder of all Jews?

Does it bother you that members of the rival movement of Hamas, Fatah, were murdered by Hamas before and during Operation Cast Lead? Some were thrown to their deaths from the tops of buildings.

Did you ever examine the casualty reports validated by Israel, or perhaps you don't believe the figures provided by American allies? Yes, civilians died - war is a terrible thing - but they were a fraction of the number of civilians who died in Iraq, Afghanistan and Serbia, owing to the measures taken by Israel to safeguard human lives.

Have you ever witnessed the aftermath of an "honor killing" in Gaza? Recently a Gaza man bludgeoned his daughter with an iron chain, because his daughter - a 27-year-old divorced mother of five - owned a cell phone and spoke to a man outside the family. Such murders go vitually unpunished by the authorities in Gaza, i.e. Hamas. These are the same authorities in whom Goldstone placed his trust.

You pride yourself on your "common sense"? You should be ashamed of yourself.


  1. I lived in Minneapolis. This is a capital of anti-Semitism in the USA. I felt it myself both at work and on the streets there. The woman could be representing very active KKK in Minneapolis. And you are asking her, if it bothers her that Hamas is calling for destruction of Israel! KKK is never ashamed of itself.

  2. McCollum is certainly not KKK. She is a left-leaning Democrat, who was joined in her opposition to the House's resolution condemning the Goldstone report by fellow Minnesota Representative Keith Ellison, the only Muslim in the House, who, while attending law school, wrote several articles in support of Louis Farrakhan. Ellison has since denounced the Nation of Islam and Farrakhan, but according to the Minneapolis Star Tribune, Ellison has accepted thousands of dollars from the Council on American-Islamic Relations. Ellison is famous for labeling the whipmaster, King Abullah of Saudi Arabia, a "visionary leader".

  3. Unfortunately, left liberals are as anti-Semitic as extreme right (think about Karl Marx!).
    What she said: "Kassams are OK, if they fell on Jews", - is anti-Semitism. Can you imagine her defending rockets falling on Minneapolis or Washington?

    She is not ashamed of herself, because her feelings have huge support in Minnesota. It is why they elected her and Ellison. There are very radicalized Muslim communities, lots of arrests have been made for terrorists activity. Romance of liberals with radical Islam is well known.

    Thank you for the quote. The logical extravaganza of extreme-left never stops to amaze me. She thinks the Hamas rockets are like kids pranks!

    ... Glad I am not in Minnesota any more!...

  4. McCollum's comparison of 122mm Grad artillery rockets fired by Hamas at Israeli cities with "drive-by gang shootings" is indeed nauseating.